Wednesday, 12 November 2008

US FACES DOWNWARD SPIRAL IN aFGHAN WAR, SAYS LEAKED INTELLIGENCE REPORT

• White House forced to reconsider strategy
• Washington wants Nato to confront drug lords

Julian Borger

US intelligence agencies believe the war in Afghanistan is in "a downward spiral", sparking an urgent strategy rethink by the Bush administration as it enters its last three months in office, it was reported yesterday.

The National Intelligence Estimate (NIE) on Afghanistan, a joint report by America's 16 spy agencies, is not due to be published until after next month's presidential election, but a draft version was leaked to US newspapers calling into question the coherence of US and Nato policy.

The document also places considerable blame on Hamid Karzai, the Afghan president, for failing to control corruption in his government. It also points to the destabilising impact of the booming opium trade, which now accounts for at least half the national economy.

The White House has ordered a review of its policy and sent a team to Kabul led by Lieutenant General Douglas Lute, the president's military adviser on Afghanistan, to assess the situation.

"We have had a tough summer. There is no doubt about it," a Nato source told the Guardian. "There are concerns, and we would share concerns the NIE has identified for better Afghan governance. We have said for some time the solution is political and not military."

The Afghan government has been reported to be holding talks with the Taliban, hosted by Saudi Arabia, but it is unclear whether those contacts would lead to comprehensive peace talks.

Robert Gates, the US defence secretary, has argued that Nato troops must confront Afghanistan's drug traffickers directly. The job has been left to Afghanistan's poorly trained and under-equipped police force. "Part of the problem that we face is that the Taliban make somewhere between $60m and $80m or more a year from the drug trafficking," Gates said at a Nato meeting in Budapest yesterday.

"... if we have the opportunity to go after drug lords and drug laboratories and try to interrupt this flow of cash to the Taliban, that seems to me like a legitimate security endeavour."

A proposed counter-narcotics mandate for Nato in Afghanistan divides opinion in Whitehall, putting the Foreign Office at odds with the Ministry of Defence.

The Foreign Office welcomed the move yesterday, saying Britain had been requesting it for years, in the face of resistance from some European allies. But British military officials were more sceptical, saying such operations would require the deployment of more forces.

"You can put your troops into counter-insurgency or you can go after the [drug trafficking] middleman but you can't do both," said a defence source.

British officers see the benefits of targeting drug laboratories and trafficking kingpins. But they argue that such operations should be undertaken primarily by Afghan forces, with Nato providing support. British diplomats are keen to emphasise that counter-narcotics efforts to date have brought results. They point to UN figures showing a 19% reduction in land under poppy cultivation last year, and a 6% fall in opium production. (The discrepancy between the two figures is explained by higher yields per hectare).

The NIE on Afghanistan appears destined to become an election issue in the final weeks of the contest between Barack Obama and John McCain.

The Pentagon plans to send another three brigades, up to 14,000 troops, to bolster the 33,000-strong US force there now, but in Budapest yesterday, US officials were urging their allies not to pull out when the American reinforcements arrive.

Meanwhile the United Arab Emirates has quietly become the 41st country contributing to the coalition effort in Afghanistan, although it is not clear what resources it intends to contribute.

The draft NIE on Afghanistan illustrates a darkening mood in western capitals. It follows a leaked French diplomatic dispatch quoting the British ambassador to Kabul, Sherard Cowper-Coles, as saying US strategy there had failed. The foreign secretary, David Miliband, said the report had "garbled" the British position.

nobel prize restores french literary

Angelique Chrisafis in Paris guardian.co.uk, Friday October 10 2008 00.01 BST The Guardian, Friday October 10 2008 Article history

The cult French writer JMG Le Clézio yesterday won the Nobel prize for literature, lifting Paris out of its depression over the nation's cultural decline.

Le Clézio, known as France's "nomad novelist", lives mainly in New Mexico in the US, in near seclusion, and is the opposite of Paris's current trend for writers' navel-gazing accounts of their sex lives.

The Swedish jury hailed his scathing critiques of urban western civilisation and the "poetic adventure and sensual ecstasy" of his stories of native populations in Africa and Latin America. His novels, whose settings range from the Sahara to Mauritius, are expected to see a massive sales boost in Britain, where he is currently out of print and barely known.

Le Clézio, 68, last year signed an open letter with other writers appealing for French literature to be more open to the wider world. Last night he batted off talk of French cultural stagnation. "I deny it," he said. "It's a very rich, very diversified culture. There's no risk of decline."

In Paris Le Clézio is seen as one of France's greatest living writers. He says his work is defined by his mixed roots. He was born in Nice but most identifies with the Indian Ocean island of Mauritius, where his Breton ancestors fled in the 18th century and lived for generations before returning to France.

He has joint Mauritian citizenship and calls the island his "little fatherland", describing himself an "exile" who grew up steeped in its mixed culture and traditions. His father, a Mauritian doctor with British citizenship, moved the family to Nigeria when Le Clézio was a child, before returning to Nice. Le Clézio studied in Britain, taught at universities in the US, Mexico and Thailand and travelled extensively with his Moroccan wife, writing about mixed relationships, and postcolonial and indigenous cultures.

Le Clézio, who publishes books at a rate of around one a year, shot to fame in France as a 23-year-old with his first novel, Le Proces-Verbal (The Interrogation), a portrait of a young man's mental illness. It won critical acclaim and a major literary prize, and his looks saw him dubbed French literature's Steve McQueen. Yesterday French media still referred to him as a blue-eyed "elegant cowboy".

Le Clézio became popular in France in the 1970s and 80s with novels set across the world. His big breakthrough came in 1980 with Desert, an award-winning novel of French colonialism seen through the eyes of a Tuareg woman in the Sahara. Since 2000 he has focused on stories of childhood and post-colonialism, drawing on his own family stories.

The Nobel jury said Le Clézio "stood out as an ecologically engaged author", citing his novels Terra Amata, The Book of Flights, War and The Giants. They called him an "explorer of a humanity beyond and below the reigning civilisation".

His acceptance speech at the ceremony in December is likely to have a political slant. A defender of Creole writers who face problems getting published, he said yesterday he would use the speech to campaign for the promotion of young writers outside the metropolitan elite. He is also vocal about war, women's rights and child prostitution in the developing world.

The French president, Nicolas Sarkozy, said: "Jean-Marie Le Clézio is a citizen of the world, son of all continents and cultures. A great traveller, he embodies the influence of France, its culture and its values in a globalised world."

Apart from the 2000 win by the Chinese-born Gao Xingjian, who has French nationality, France has not won a Nobel literature prize for over 20 years and has been desperate for a return to the golden era of winners such as Albert Camus, Jean-Paul Sartre and Andre Gide.

Nobel award restores French literary pride• Winning author denies France has stagnated
• Country dreams of a return to days of Sartre

'A beautiful portrait'
"This [the portrayal of the protagonist, Ethel] is undoubtedly one of the most beautiful portraits Le Clézio has ever written, flickering, fragile, never closed in on itself, never frozen in marble or gripped in the vice of oppressive psychological certitudes.

"Its autobiographical role has been reduced to the simplest of expressions. So no confusion or confession, just a simple gesture of intimacy... [Le Clézio] does not give any moral lesson. Subtle and generous, but at the same time highly skilful ... his art is all about compassion and empathy - and also rebellion. It is rare to enter with such emotion into the feelings of fictional characters."

• Extract from Le Monde review of Le Clézio's latest novel, Ritournelle de la faim (Chorus of Hunger)

Tuesday, 11 November 2008

Obama got Gustav wrong The Democrat gave his rival the chance to score points as the hurricane approached New Orleans

In the combination of New Orleans and hurricanes, we have the most powerful argument possible for the necessity of "change". It's all there: gaping inequality, deep racism, crumbling public infrastructure, global warming, rampant corruption, the Blackwater-isation of the public sector. And none of it is in the past tense. In New Orleans whole neighbourhoods have gone to seed, Charity hospital remains shuttered, public housing has been deliberately destroyed - and the levee system is still far from repaired.

Gustav should have been political rat poison for the Republicans, no matter how well it was managed. Yet, as Peter Baker noted in the New York Times, "rather than run away from the hurricane and its political risks, Mr McCain ran toward it". If this strategy worked, it was at least partly because Barack Obama has been running away from New Orleans for his entire campaign.

Unlike John Edwards, who started and ended his nomination bid surrounded by the decay of New Orleans's Ninth Ward, Obama has shied away from the powerful symbolism the city offers. He waited almost a year after Hurricane Katrina to visit New Orleans and spent just half a day there ahead of the Louisiana primary. During the Democratic convention, Michelle Obama, Hillary Clinton and Joe Biden made no mention of New Orleans in their keynotes. Bill Clinton spared just a few words: "Katrina and cronyism."

In his Denver speech, Obama did invoke a government "that sits on its hands while a major American city drowns before our eyes". But that only scratches the surface of what happened to New Orleans's poorest residents, who were first forcibly relocated and then forced to watch from afar as their homes, schools and hospitals were stolen. As Obama spoke in Denver, families in New Orleans were already packing their bags in anticipation of Gustav, steeling themselves for yet another evacuation. They heard not even a perfunctory "our thoughts and prayers are with you" from the Democratic candidate for president.

There are plenty of political reasons for this, of course. Obama's campaign is pitching itself to the middle class, not the class of discarded people New Orleans represents. The problem is that by remaining virtually silent about the most dramatic domestic outrage in modern US history, Obama created a political vacuum. When Gustav hit, all McCain needed to do to fill it was show up. Sure, it was cynical for McCain to claim the hurricane zone as a campaign backdrop; but it was Obama who left that potent terrain vacant.

Until now, Obama's supporters have largely accepted the campaign's assessment of the compromises necessary to win, offering only gentle prodding. The fact that the Republicans have turned New Orleans to their advantage should put an end to this blind obedience.

Republicans have a better attitude towards their candidate. When they don't like McCain's positions, they change them. Take the hottest-button issue of the campaign: offshore oil drilling. Just four months ago, it was not even on the radar. During the Republican primary, the issue barely came up, and when it did, McCain did not support it. None of this bothered former House Speaker Newt Gingrich and his newly minted American Solutions for Winning the Future. Gingrich waited patiently for what his party loves most: a crisis. It arrived in May, when oil approached $130 a barrel. First came a petition to lower petrol prices by opening up domestic drilling (nonsense). Next was a poll, packed with laughably leading questions: "Some people have suggested that, to combat the rising cost of energy and reduce dependence on foreign energy sources, the United States should use more of its own domestic energy reserves, including the oil and coal it already has here in the US. Do you support or oppose this idea?" You can guess what people said. Two weeks later, McCain flipped on offshore oil drilling.

There was always a risk attached to making offshore drilling the centrepiece of the McCain campaign, since it is not nearly as safe as its advocates claim. Environmentalists have been trying to point this out, but nothing makes the case quite as forcefully as a category five hurricane rocking oil platforms in the Gulf of Mexico, forcing evacuations and raising the spectre of a serious spill.

Gustav was one of those rare moments when political arguments are made by reality, not rhetoric. It was the time to simply point and say: "This is why we oppose more drilling." It was also the time to recall that during hurricanes Katrina and Rita, the official Minerals Management Service report found more than 100 accidents leading to a total of 743,400 gallons of oil spilled throughout the region. To put that in perspective, 100,000 gallons is classified as a "major spill". If one is feeling particularly bold, a category five hurricane is also an opportune time to mention that scientists see a link between heavier storms and warming ocean temperatures - warmed in part by the fossil fuels being extracted from those fallible platforms.

Obama was not able to make these kinds of arguments when Gustav hit. That's because his campaign had made another "strategic" decision: to compromise on offshore oil drilling. Again a vacuum that had been opened up was rapidly filled by the Republicans, who instantly (and absurdly) linked the hurricane to the need for "energy security". The morning after Gustav made landfall, Bush called for more drilling. Earlier, McCain had visited the hurricane zone with his new running mate, Sarah Palin, whose sole prior claim to national fame was telling cable shows that "we need to drill, drill, drill".

In moments of crisis, it is possible to speak hard truths with great force and clarity. But when the truth has gone silent, lies, boldly told, will work almost as well.

· This column was first published in The Nation

· naomiklein.org

Anyone can be governor general in Australia- unless you're an Aborigine: Germaine Greer, The Guardian.

Six months ago Michael Jeffery, the then governor general of Australia, stuck for something to say about his female replacement, declared: "Anybody can be the governor general in [Australia] and that's what makes it such a great place" - as if the other 14 Commonwealth realms that pick a stand-in for the Queen were somehow less democratic than Australia.

When it comes to choosing a head of state Australia is the least adventurous of the dominions. The 25 incumbents include one prince, two earls, two viscounts, seven barons and nine knights, plus an archbishop, a politician and a major-general. Hitherto, all have been men; none has been from an ethnic minority. Canada appointed its first woman, a member of the French-speaking minority, a quarter of a century ago: the second, Adrienne Clarkson, was born in China; and the present incumbent, who is female and black, was born in Haiti.

The governor general's job is to represent the Queen. What the Queen would not do, the governor general, whether male or female, must not do either. The governor general needs to know how to talk to visiting monarchs, ambassadors, sportsmen and hoi polloi without actually saying anything, while showing interest in everything and concern about nothing. The governor general has to deliver the speech at the opening of parliament utterly deadpan, without so much as raising an eyebrow. Governors general, like British queens, have to do as prime ministers tell them. The poorest Australian has more rights than the governor general, who may not demonstrate, may not carry a placard, may not write so much as a letter for publication.

The outgoing governor general managed to keep his mouth shut and nose clean until this, his very last week, when he suddenly uttered an opinion. Referring to the Aboriginal population, or as he put it the 520,000 "people with indigenous blood", he said: "I suspect that about ... 400,000 of those are already integrated satisfactorily ... to such an extent that you don't hear about them. They're doing what we would look upon as living normal Australian lives." According to him it was only the 100,000 or so in the remote areas who had been "doing it hard for many years".

All the people struggling in urban areas to reverse the devastation of poverty, displacement, imprisonment, drugs and alcohol were flabbergasted, but the governor general was groping towards a very blunt and rather wobbly point. Many people with "indigenous blood" have never lived as Aborigines. For them indigenous blood can be a passport to all kinds of benefits, including cushy sinecures in the establishment. Time was when these people would have passed for white; these days they tend to pass for black. Where once the black ancestors were hidden, it is now the white ancestors who are never mentioned.

Australia appears to have adopted the invidious one-drop policy that so vitiated assistance given to Canada's First Nations. What is even more confusing is that Torres Strait Islanders, who came to Australia as indentured labour, were lumped in with indigenous hunter-gatherer peoples, though they at no time claimed sovereignty over any part of the continent. If Jeffery had grasped the real stinging nettle, and voiced a suspicion about just how diluted "indigenous blood" has been, the outcry would have been even shriller.

Pat Dodson, descendant of the Yawuru nation, ordained Catholic priest and former chairman of the Council for Aboriginal Reconciliation, thundered from Alice Springs: "We're not living normal lives. We're totally over-represented in the political indicators. We're dying a lot younger. We don't have the educational opportunities." Of non-indigenous Australians, 49% will complete year 12 of their schooling; only 14% of indigenous children in remote areas will get that far, and in the cities the proportion rises only to a third.

What was worse than the governor general's touching innocence about the realities of urban Aboriginal life was his bland assumption that total assimilation was the only satisfactory goal. In Dodson's words, Jeffery's statement "really denies the uniqueness of who the indigenous people are and what their contribution to this country can be in their own right, as if they have nothing to contribute except the absorption of the culture the west has offered us. It's a pretty damnable statement if that's the case." Marcia Langton, professor of indigenous studies at the University of Melbourne and descendant of the Yiman nation, refused to comment as to do so would be "too dangerous".

Among the people tipped to take over Jeffery's $365,000-a-year job was Lowitja O'Donohue, descendant of the Yankunytjatjara people and founder chairman of the now disbanded Aboriginal and Torres Strait Islander Commission. It was not to be. The choice of the prime minister, Kevin Rudd, alighted on a fellow Queenslander, Quentin Bryce - a woman who already had the job of state governor. Australian media are now congratulating the country on having matured enough to be ready for a woman governor general. Belize was mature enough in 1981, when Dame Minita Gordon took office. New Zealand, always more mature than Australia, has had two Dames do the job, Catherine Tizard and Sylvia Cartwright. Barbados has had Dame Nita Barrow, and the Bahamas Dame Ivy Dumont. St Lucia currently has Dame Pearlette Louisy as head of state, Antigua and Barbuda Dame Louise Lake-Tack. Only Grenada, Jamaica, Papua New Guinea, St Kitts and Nevis, Solomon Islands, and Tuvalu have yet to choose a woman for governor general.

Bryce - who was sworn in yesterday - is now commander-in-chief of Australia's armed forces. The queen wouldn't dream of issuing orders to the troops, so neither does the governor general. The only governor general to have taken the role of commander-in-chief at all seriously was Adrienne Clarkson, who visited Canadian troops in Kosovo and the Gulf. She came to the job after years as a talkshow host and TV presenter, so was used to offering style in lieu of substance; but even so she blundered into one footling controversy after another. On one mortifying occasion she took precedence over the Queen, apparently because some bewildered underling had not grasped that Clarkson was head of state only when the Queen wasn't there.

Bryce is reported to have said under media bombardment that Australia will become a republic when the people decide, so there is a glimmer of hope that the first woman to take this most nugatory of jobs could also be the first republican. If so, she'd better learn pretty quickly to keep it to herself.


· Germaine Greer is professor emeritus of English literature and comparative studies at Warwick University

Saturday, 8 November 2008

All the cliches about colour obscure the real challenges awaiting Obama The world must get over its hysteria. The next US leader has Russia to deal wi

Simon Jenkins guardian.co.uk, Friday November 7 2008

The world wept with joy on Tuesday night. Probably more such tears were shed than in all history. The reason was not that a Democrat had beaten a Republican, or that the new man is young and has a gift for turning banality into rhetoric. The emotion was because Barack Obama is black.

I too wept, but I did so because the massive hope loaded on to Obama seems so naive and cannot be justified. The election of this man, mesmeric since I first heard of him in Illinois four years ago and read his memoir, may symbolise the advance of a once-oppressed group of Americans, and by proxy of non-whites the world over. But embracing someone for where he comes from rather than for what he may do has been the hubris of politics throughout history. No service is done to Obama by overstating his revolution as a second coming.

The most overheard media cliche is that "America will never be the same again". Yes it will, as it was when it last elected a Democratic president. Only if we break from the crypto-racist mindset that sees Obama as a black man first and all else far behind can the odds on a successful presidency be assessed.

The election result reflected a normal pendulum swing to a conventional Democrat, as is likely in time of unpopular war and economic distress. Nothing in George Bush's wretched term of office became him like the leaving of it: he made Obama's succession inevitable. The heroes of the campaign were the primary voters, who had put up Obama rather than Hillary Clinton to win the proffered palm.

Obama's 52% of the vote was not a landslide. It was the distortions of an electoral college system that served (as in the House of Commons) to turn an unexceptional four-point swing into an apparently overwhelming victory.

The race spin being put on the result is quite wrong. The percentage of black people among those voting on Tuesday was up just two points, from 11 to 13%. Within the white electorate, Obama actually increased the Democratic share. The reported prominence of "the economy" in the minds of voters, against "security" in 2004, gave a natural boost to the Democratic vote. Add the unpopularity of the Iraq war, McCain's reckless choice of running mate, and Obama's brilliant campaign technique to get out his vote, and there is reason enough for the winning Democrat margin.

Nor is Obama the salvationist figure assumed by many abroad. Tuesday was no black insurgency. The victory speech contained not one reference to his racial background. That ageing American icon, Jesse Jackson, hated Obama until Tuesday night. He was no son of slavery. Indeed the fascination of his memoir lies in the search by a member of an all-white family for an explanation of the colour of his skin.

The new president is better seen as a classic American mix of freebooting immigrant and poor but educated mother, committed to a college education for her son. His story could be that of any president of Scots/Irish descent, rising through law school to emerge as the smoothly intellectual liberal derided by the Clintons during the campaign. Constant references to his colour obscure his real strengths and possible weaknesses.

The one gain to Obama from the hysteria that has greeted his election will come if he can convert it into something politically bankable. He will - such is politics - soon be campaigning for re-election. The Republicans may go through contortions of self-examination, but their party is hardly finished. Evangelical conservatism - political and economic as well as religious - is not dead. Opponents will be prowling Congress and the airwaves, waiting to pounce on each Obama setback.

Obama's popularity must be deployed early to give the conservative Washington machine, awash in interests and lobbies, the momentum it needs to "effect change". Bush's adoption of Keynesian remedialism was welcome, but was not enough to save the economy (and himself) from recession. Obama must no longer pander to an army of grimly implacable unions, farmers, cartels, businesses and traders demanding satisfaction.

Americans have elected a leader not just for themselves but for a wide swath of peoples around the world. They cried out for Obama and America granted them their wish. But the greater the expectation of this man, the more furious will be the backlash if he proves a disappointment.

There is a global detritus of American ineptitude and unpopularity to be cleared. The blundering mammoth that is America's global military projection must be curbed. Intelligence must return to foreign relations. Obama could indicate a start by closing Guantánamo Bay on day one. Will he?

Dare he stop torture, accept the Geneva conventions, get tough with Israel, change policy on Russia, make peace with Iran? He has promised to get out of Iraq and fast. But he must also unleash a ferocious pragmatism as "war creep" envelopes Afghanistan, and stop making puerile pledges to invade Pakistan and bomb border villages.

Pakistan was visited this week by a man poised to hold the leading role in the Obama presidency, General David Petraeus. It has taken Washington seven years to realise that the keys to the gates of Kabul lie in Islamabad. But that merely indicates how catastrophic it would be for Obama to continue the belligerent campaign line towards that theatre. The region cries out for the quality most lacking in Republican diplomacy, subtlety.

Afghanistan could yet be to Obama what Vietnam was to the last great civil rights champion in the White House, Lyndon Johnson. All Democratic presidents eager for re-election find it easiest to buy popularity and a macho image by acting belligerently abroad. Obama has yet to indicate that he is an exception to the rule.

An early test will be his response to the extraordinary sabre-rattling by the Russian president, Dmitry Medvedev. Medvedev's proposal to station missiles in the Russian exclave of Kaliningrad between Poland and Lithuania is a crude reaction to George Bush's location of defence installations in a number of former Warsaw pact countries. It is so clearly a challenge to Obama's resolve that it demands an immediate reply. The opportunity is for a classic show of firmness combined with an openness to negotiate. Kaliningrad could yet be Obama's Cuban missile crisis - the geographical parallel is eerily similar - before he has even taken office.

The exhilaration of the past week has been palpable. I have lost count of the Americans who have said with relief: "I am tired with being hated everywhere I go. Suddenly I am loved." The moment is Rooseveltian. At a time of seeming ubiquitous misery, America not for the first time has pulled an iron from the fire. It has found a messiah.

But I still prefer to see Obama not as a black man but as a talented leader of evident competence and sagacity who could use his charisma to bind people together, and his intelligence to chart a way forward. These are the specific qualities the world needs now. We should place our faith in them and not in race or colour.

Fatah and Hamas in unity government talks

• Egypt sponsors meeting between factions
• Negotiators want end to Gaza economic blockade

* Rory McCarthy in Gaza city guardian.co.uk, Friday November 7 2008

The rival Palestinian factions Hamas and Fatah will meet in Cairo on Sunday for the first time in more than a year in an Egyptian-led effort to agree a unified government and end their divisions.

Egyptian officials have prepared an outline deal that would include a "national reconciliation government", but it is short on details and could take weeks of negotiation. The last effort at a unity government, arranged by the Saudis in February 2007, collapsed and the factions reverted to a near civil war until Hamas seized full control of Gaza months later.

"This will probably be the last opportunity for Fatah and Hamas to put aside their differences and put an end to division and launch a comprehensive national dialogue," said Mkhaimar Abu Sada, a political scientist at Gaza's
al-Azhar University.

The talks will centre on establishing a government with the goal of ending the economic siege of Gaza, reforming the security forces under a national leadership and preparing for fresh presidential and parliamentary elections.

A united government would present a challenge and perhaps an opportunity for fresh policymaking for the US and Europe, which refused to talk to Hamas and isolated the movement soon after it won Palestinian elections in 2006. Since then Hamas-run Gaza has been under economic blockade. Israel limits most imports and has banned all exports. Egypt has also kept its one crossing mostly closed.

Israel is not likely to deal with any government with a Hamas component unless it offers recognition of Israel, a halt to violence and acceptance of past peace deals - something Hamas has consistently refused. Fatah also wants to secure an endorsement for Mahmoud Abbas, the Fatah leader and Palestinian president, to continue in office for another year after his term formally ends on January 8. If Hamas refuses it will probably challenge Abbas's legitimacy and may appoint its own president in Gaza.

Hamas wants an end to Gaza's blockade and is demanding entry into and reform of the Palestine Liberation Organisation, the umbrella group regarded as the "sole legitimate representative of the Palestinian people". All peace talks with Israel are carried out by Abbas as PLO leader and it was the PLO which in 1993 formally recognised Israel's right to exist as part of the Oslo process. Hamas's entry into the PLO has been discussed but never agreed. It is on the agenda in Cairo but the Islamist movement is pushing hard for a deal.

"The PLO is representing the Palestinian people and its political programme should be discussed among all the political factions and represent all the authorities," said Taher al-Nunu, a Hamas spokesman in Gaza.

Many Palestinians believe there was pressure from the US on Abbas not to deal with Hamas but after the election that may now be waning. Yet Abbas's failure in the past year to secure a peace agreement has weakened his position. "Many people didn't think Hamas was going to last as long as it did," said Abu Sada. "But ... instead of being squeezed it has got much stronger and imposed order in Gaza."

"People are fed up with both of them," said Ali Jarbawi, professor of political science at Birzeit University in Ramallah. "They are fighting over power in an authority still under occupation."

Tutsi rebels in Congo accused of murdering civilians

• Bodies litter streets of former Hutu stronghold
• UN moves in armour and forces to halt killings

Chris McGreal in Rutshur guardian.co.uk, Friday November 7 2008

Tutsi rebels in eastern Congo have been accused of summarily killing civilians as they seized a town that had been the stronghold of Hutu militias, and forcing tens of thousands of people from their homes. After two days of fighting, scores of bodies lay in the streets and homes of Kiwanja, a town adjacent to Rutshuru, which was seized by the Tutsi renegade general Laurent Nkunda last week. Residents claimed his forces shot unarmed civilians after accusing them of supporting Hutu militias.

As calm returned to Kiwanja yesterday, Nkunda's forces seized at least two other villages in the area, Nyanzale and Kikuku. The UN said it was moving armoured vehicles and its forces into the area in an attempt to protect civilians and prevent further advances by the Tutsi rebels.

Most of Kiwanja's 35,000 residents were driven out of the town and into Rutshuru, where they were left to fend for themselves during the night in driving rain. Women and children, dragging goats and bundles of clothing, straggled in a line that stretched for miles. Many camped out at the town's stadium, without food or water.

"The Tutsis came and ordered us to leave," said Jean Bakenda. "They shot people who refused to go or who they said were against them. They shot one man right in front of me and told me they would shoot me if I didn't run to Rutshuru straight away. I only had time to grab my wife and children and nothing else."

One house in Kiwanja contained the bodies of five men.

Another resident, Simo Bramporiki, said his wife and child were shot dead. "They knocked on the doors. When the people opened, they killed them with their guns," he said.

Nkunda denied that his National Congress for the Defence of the People (CNDP) forces had killed civilians, saying the dead were Hutu fighters in civilian clothes.

The UN peacekeeping mission, which did not intervene from its nearby base despite its mandate to protect civilians, said it was investigating the killings.

The fighting in Kiwanja appears to have been provoked by an assault by a regional traditional militia, the Mai Mai, and Rwandan Hutu extremists, the Democratic Front for the Liberation of Rwanda (FDLR) who fled their own country after carrying out the 1994 genocide. The Congolese government's army has often fought in league with the Hutu extremists.

Kiwanja was a stronghold of Hutu support after thousands moved there in recent years to escape fighting and armed gangs in rural areas. Many were reluctant to settle in Rutshuru, which is regarded locally as part of the ancient Tutsi kingdom and is therefore a target for Nkunda.

A ceasefire continued to hold around the region's main town, Goma. The UN has described the defence of Goma as a "red line" and yesterday reiterated that it would use all the force at its disposal, including helicopter gunships and armoured vehicles, to protect the town. UN peacekeepers were digging in to the north of Goma, just short of Nkunda's lines.

Nkunda yesterday renewed a threat to attack Goma if the government kept up what he said were attacks on his troops in order to provoke conflict and western intervention against him. "My soldiers are only defending themselves from attacks," he said. "This is a treasonous government and if it does not negotiate with us then we will force it to negotiate."

Adolphe Muzito, Congo's prime minister, said his government was now ready to talk directly to Nkunda's rebels, despite refusing to earlier in the week. "The government is ready to listen to all the armed groups. I am ready to listen, to receive the grievances of other groups ... including those of the CNDP," Muzito said.

It was unclear, however, if that was a serious offer of talks, or political positioning ahead of a summit of regional leaders in Nairobi today that will focus on the conflict. Congo's president, Joseph Kabila, and the Rwandan leader, Paul Kagame, are expected to attend, along with the UN secretary general, Ban Ki-moon. But Nkunda and the FDLR will not be there.

Rwanda is demanding that Congo and the UN fulfil a commitment to disarm the Hutu extremists on its border who control about 40% of territory in the two Congolese provinces neighbouring Rwanda, North and South Kivu. The FDLR is committed to overthrowing the present Rwandan government and is raising a new generation of fighters imbued with the same hatred of Tutsis.